The four-seven debate

The four-seven debate by Michael C. Kalton Download PDF EPUB FB2

This book is an annotated translation, with introduction and commentary, of the correspondence between Yi Hwang (T'oegye, ) and Ki Taesung (Kobong, ) and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Song Hon (Ugye, ), known as the Four-Seven Debate, the most famous philosophical controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian by: 6.

This book is an annotated translation, with introduction and commentary, of the correspondence between Yi Hwang (T'oegye, ) and Ki Taesung (Kobong, ) and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Song Hon (Ugye, ), known as the Four-Seven Debate, the most famous philosophical controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian thought.

The Four-Seven Debate was one of the longest-running and insightful controversies in the history of Korean Confucianism. The basic problem concerned the nature and relationship between the Four Sprouts, first described by Mengzi, and the Seven Emotions, depicted in a variety of classical texts such as the Doctrine of the : Philip J.

Ivanhoe. The Four-Seven Debate was a debate in sixteenth century Korean Neo-Confucian philosophy, between Yi Hwang (Toegye, ) and Gi Dae-seung (Gobong, ), and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Seong Hon (Ugye, ), about the ways in which the Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings are similar to, or different from, each other The Four Beginnings (compassion.

The Four-Seven Debate was an academic discussion which focused on the question of The four-seven debate book source of the Four Beginnings (ssu-tuanbl) and the Seven Feelings (ch'i-ch'ingbm).

The concept of the Four Beginnings appeared for the first time in the book of Menciusbn: "The mind of compassion is. This book is an annotated translation, with introduction and commentary, of the correspondence between Yi Hwang (T'oegye, ) and Ki Taesung (Kobong, ) and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Song Hon (Ugye, ), known as the Four-Seven Debate, the most famous philosophical controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian by: On the book: The Four-Seven Debate — By Michael Kalton T’oe-Gye (Yi Hwang) Yi Hwang ( – ) is one of the two most prominent Korean Confucian scholars of the Joseon Dynasty, the other being his younger contemporary Yi I (Yulgok).

[1]. Taesŭng (–72) in the famous Four-Seven debate, which discussed the relationship between Mencius’s four basic human feelings—commiseration, shame, modesty, and right and wrong—and seven emotions, such as anger and joy, raised the level of Confucian dialogue to.

WHEN SHE WOKE By Hillary Jordan If THE HANDMAIDS TALE and THE SCARLET LETTER were to have a child it most certainly would be this wonderful book, WHEN SHE WOKE.

This well written book captures you with the opening scene of a young woman lying on a table in a bare room, covered only by a paper gown while being televised to millions of homes/5(K). Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for The Four-Seven Debate: An Annotated Translation of the Most Famous Controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian Thought (SUNY series in Korean Studies) at Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users.5/5.

Introduction to the Four-Seven Debate. Background. The Four-Seven Debate. The Toegye-Kobong Debate. The Yulgok-Ugye Debate.

The Importance of the Four-Seven Debate ; 1. Toegye's Letter to Kobong ; 2. Kobong's Letter to Toegye on the Four Beginnings ; Seven Feelings Thesis ; 3. The Four-Seven Debate Read More This book is an annotated translation, with introduction and commentary, of the correspondence between Yi Hwang (T'oegye, ) and Ki Taesung (Kobong, ) and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Song Hon (Ugye, ), known as the Four-Seven Debate, the most famous philosophical controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian.

The Four-Seven Debate between Yi Toegye and Gi Gobong and Its Philosophical Purport The reach of Chinese Confucianism extended to Korea and Japan, and followed the Chinese diaspora wherever the Chinese went, whether it was by.

The Four-Seven Debate: An Annotated Translation of the Most Famous Controversy in Korean Neo-Confucian Thought by Kalton, Michael and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at Start studying 4/7 debate.

Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The Four-Seven Debate was a debate in sixteenth century Korean Neo-Confucian philosophy, between Yi Hwang (Toegye, ) and Gi Dae-seung (Gobong, ), and between Yi I (Yulgok, ) and Seong Hon (Ugye, ), about the ways in which the Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings are similar to, or different from, each other.

The Four-Seven Debate (hangul:사칠속편, hanja:四七續篇): discusses Mencius's philosophy with Gi Dae-seung; Ten Diagrams on Sage Learning.

The Neo-Confucian literature of Seonghaksipdo was composed by Yi Hwang in for King Seonjo. It is a series of lectures for rulers through examples of past : 이황. Among the philosophical debates of Korean Neo-Confucianism, the author of the paper focuses on the Four–Seven Debate (a philosophical debate about the moral psychological nature of the four moral emotions and the seven morally indiscrete emotions) to analyze its li – qi metaphysics (a philosophical explanation of the universe through the intricate and interactive relation between the two cosmic Cited by: 1.

Buy The Four-Seven Debate by Michael C. Kalton, Oaksook C. Kim from Waterstones today. Click and Collect from your local Waterstones or get FREE UK delivery on orders over £Book Edition: Annotated Edition. The Importance of the Four-Seven Debate -- 1.

Toegye's Letter to Kobong -- 2. Kobong's Letter to Toegye on the Four Beginnings -- Seven Feelings Thesis -- 3. Toegye's Reply to Kobong Arguing the Distinction of the Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings in Terms of Principle and Material Force -- 4. The four-seven debate: an annotated translation of the most famous controversy in Korean neo-Confucian thought.

Albany: State University of New York Press. MLA Citation. Kalton, Michael C. and Kim, Oaksook Chun.A Ruby and Triangled Sign upon the Forehead of Taurus: Modalities of Revelation in Megalithic Archaeoastronomy and James Joyce’s Novels Ulysses and Finnegans WakeCited by: 1. This article aims to phenomenologically examine T’oegye’s arguments on the Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings, attempting a theoretical reconstruction through “founding” and “alterity”, so as to reveal the relations and differences between the Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings.

On the one hand, the Four Beginnings constitute a founding substratum, on the top of which the Seven Author: Xi Lin, Liju Xing.